Investor Update
The Westerly · Pewaukee, WI
Contact investor@matterdevelops.com if you need access.
Matter Development
ICAP Development
Investor Update · Development Lease Up

The Westerly
Pewaukee

409 Swan Rd  ·  Pewaukee, WI  ·  Quarter III 2026

138 Units
Total Community Size
67 · 55 · 16
IL · AL · MC Units
Apr 2025
Opening Date
The Westerly Pewaukee — Exterior
Scroll to explore
Asset Overview

An award-winning senior living continuum of care
in Wisconsin's Lake Country.

★ New Recognition
American Society of Interior Design — 2025 ASID Design Excellence Awards, Continuum of Care
★ Recognition
Milwaukee Business Journal — Best Senior Living Community, New Construction (2026 Real Estate Awards)
★ Recognition
The Daily Reporter — Top Projects Honoree, recognizing Wisconsin's top construction projects (2026 Award)
The Westerly — Indoor Pool
Resort-style indoor pool, open year-round for residents
The Westerly — Lobby
Welcoming lobby with wayfinding to community amenities
The Westerly — Library & Game Room
Library and game room, a favorite gathering spot
Community
The WesterlyIndependent Living · Assisted Living · Memory Care
Location
409 Swan Rd, Pewaukee, WI ↗ Lake Country submarket — Waukesha County
Total Units
138 Units67 IL · 45 AL · 10 High-Acuity AL · 16 MC
Opening Date
April 2025Approx. 1.5 years of operating history as of Quarter III 2026
Ownership & Management
Matter Developmentmatterdevelops.com ↗ICAP Developmenticap-dev.com ↗Co-developers & sponsorsKoru Health (KMJV Operation LLC)Operator
Balance Sheet Summary
$46.3MTotal transaction basis$31.5MJohnson Bank debt; interest-only until 12/21/26 at a blended rate of ~7.30% (rate swap); matures 12/21/26 with a 36-month extension option$14.5MOf the extension debt locked at 5.89% on a forward swap; amortizing payments begin 2/1/27
Current Operations

Operating performance through a successful
lease-up in process.

Current Occupancy
83.3%
115 of 138 units occupied as of the current reporting month (rent roll, physical occupancy).
★ Deposits Secured for 121 Units · 87.7%
Considering units out of service, occupancy is 115 of 128 units, or 89.8%. See DHS License Status below.
Annualized NOI (Current Qtr.)
$2.59M
36.0% operating margin on the current quarter's revenue of $1.80M, annualized.
Lease-Up Progress by Area
Independent Living (IL)†76 of 76 units · 100.0%
Assisted Living (AL)*23 of 46 units · 50.0%
Memory Care (MC)‡16 of 16 units · 100.0%
* 10 units out of service due to DHS license pending. Occupancy is 63.9% considering units out of service.
† IL and AL occupied unit count can vary based on demand, which is permissible under our license. Some IL and AL residents may be spouses living together, classified as an AL unit.
‡ 17 beds occupied, considering double occupancy.
Year-to-Date Performance — Current Year
YTD Revenue
$4.88M
Year-to-date, −0.8% vs. budget
YTD Operating Expenses
$3.09M
63.3% of revenue, +4.9% over budget
YTD Net Operating Income
$1.79M
36.7% margin, −9.4% vs. budget
Actual Quarterly Performance Two Quarters Ago Prior Quarter Current Quarter
Total Revenue $1,343,675 $1,737,795 $1,797,252
Operating Expenses $905,448 $1,034,005 $1,149,531
Net Operating Income $438,228 $703,791 $647,720
NOI Growth (QoQ) +568.5% +60.6% −8.0%
Quarter-over-Quarter NOI Commentary
Operations Highlights

Progressing through lease-up, with a clear
path to stabilization.

◈ Forward Leasing Target
Positive

Beyond Q3 ending occupancy of 115 units, deposits are secured for an additional 6 units, bringing effective occupancy to 121 units (87.7%). Management continues to prioritize AL lease-up, where 13 of 36 in-service units remain available. Remaining units are studios and the smallest one-bedroom apartment in the unit mix. To help increase census, we are looking to prioritize respite stays and rapid admissions from health system social workers.

Westerly maintains an active waiting list, which includes 19 IL, 4 AL, and 7 MC. Residents with an interest in IL may be accommodated with internal IL to AL transitions.

◈ Revenue Mix
Strong

Revenue mix remains 100% private pay, with no reliance on Medicaid or other government reimbursement — supporting rate stability and a cleaner underwriting profile as the community stabilizes. Management may consider adding a few Medicaid residents to the unit mix to fill remaining open AL units (where it is staffing efficient).

◈ DHS License Status
Pending

The community's highest-level assisted living license remains pending with the Department of Health Services, but we have received more direct communication from them recently and are now focused on issuance of the license by the end of the year. As discussed previously, the delay affects only a small 10-unit wing, but the focus on the out-of-service units is becoming more acute as few remaining units are left to occupy in other areas of the building.

◈ Staffing & Operations
On Track

Key department-head positions remain filled, and Management continues to hire and train for AL and MC operations as occupancy grows. Labor cost per resident day averaged about $56 in Q3 versus $53 in Q2, but is down from $77 in October 2025. Overtime averaged 7.6% of labor cost versus 9.5% in Q2, though it rose through the quarter to 8.7% in September. Outside staffing spiked to $23K in September, and Management is monitoring the balance between overtime and agency labor and prioritizing permanent care hires. Resident turnover remains low, with 6 move-outs against 20 move-ins in Q3.

◈ Distribution Status
Building Reserves

Operations of The Westerly have started to build cash reserves; however, regular distributions may only occur after the Company converts its loan from interest-only payments to a fully amortizing loan. This conversion is set to occur in December. While the managers of the Company are closely monitoring stabilized operations to determine if principal payments should start sooner, the plan is to remain on interest-only payments until December to maximize cash flow in 2026. Investors should expect an update on further distributions in the first quarter of 2027.

◈ NOI Performance
Monitoring

Net operating income of $647,720 was down 8.0% from the prior quarter, with operating margin of 36.0% versus 40.5%. Revenue grew 3.4% to $1.80M, while operating expenses rose 11.2%, including the one-time and timing-related items noted above.

Questions? Reach out directly.
Matter Development & ICAP Development
Matter Development — 2675 N Mayfair Road, Suite 200  ·  Wauwatosa, WI 53226
ICAP Development — 1830 N Hubbard St, Suite 700  ·  Milwaukee, WI 53212
Matter Development
Managing Director & Founder
Aaron R. Matter
414-409-1295
aaron@matterdevelops.com
ICAP Development
Managing Partner
Brian R. Adamson
414-412-8633
brian.adamson@icap-dev.com